Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgendaPacket 5-4-22 Gregory Smith, Chair Vernell Doyle Lloyd Yavener, Vice Chair Michael Lushbaugh Ann Aldrich Kourtney Lowery Edith Wallace Jeffrey A. Cline, BOCC Rep HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION OF WASHINGTON COU NTY, MARYLAND WWW.WASHCO-MD.NET 100 West Washington Street, Suite 2600 | Hagerstown, MD 21740 | P: 240.313.2430 | F: 240.313.2431 | TDD: 7-1-1 AGENDA May 4, 2022, 7:00 p.m. Washington County Administration Complex, 100 West Washington Street, Room 2001, Hagerstown, MD 21740 **Masks are encouraged in all County Buildings regardless of vaccination status** CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL MINUTES 1. Minutes of the April 6, 2022 meeting * NEW BUSINESS 1. Permit 2022-01421 – 4835 Branch Avenue, Sharpsburg – (Discussion/Action) 1500sq.ft. pavilion on concrete slab, pressure treated wood, pre-engineered roof trusses (ANTIETAM OVERLAY) * 2. SHA Project No.WA461B21, Interstate 68 over Creek Road Replacement - (Discussion/Action) request for concurrence that there would be no historic properties affected by the replacement of Bridge Nos.2107603 and 2107604, IS 68 over Creek Road in Washington County * 3. SHA Project No.WA466A21, Interstate 70 at St Paul Road Replacement – (Discussion/Action) request for concurrence that there would be no historic properties affected by the replacement of Bridge Nos. 2110203 and 2110204, I-70 over St. Paul Road Eastbound and Westbound * (continued on page 2) OTHER BUSINESS 1. Design Guidelines (Discussion/Action) – Discussion of changes to Guidelines and request for consensus to move forward with public hearing of the document. * 2. Staff Report a. Staff Reviews * b. Staff Updates i. Tolson’s Save the Date ii. Smithsburg Historical Society April 2022 iii. HAC John Frye Registration iv. Preservation Month Theme Announced by National Trust – People Saving Places ADJOURNMENT UPCOMING MEETING 1. Wednesday, June 1, 2022, 7:00 p.m. (Date/Time may change due to hearing requirements) *attachments The Historic District Commission reserves the right to vary the order in which the cases are called. Individuals requiring special accommodations are requested to contact the Washington County Planning Department at 240- 313-2430 to make arrangements no later than ten (10) days prior to the meeting. Notice is given that the agenda may be amended at any time up to and including the meeting. MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION FOR WASHINGTON COUNTY April 6, 2022 The Washington County Historic District Commission held its regular monthly meeting on Wednesday, April 6, 2022 at 7:00 p.m. in the Washington County Administration Complex, 100 W Washington Street, Room 2001, Hagerstown, MD. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL The Chairman called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. Commission members present were: Greg Smith, Chairman, Ann Aldrich, Lloyd Yavener, Vernell Doyle, Michael Lushbaugh, Kourtney Lowery, Edie Wallace and Ex-officio County Commissioner Jeff Cline. Staff members present were: Washington County Department of Planning & Zoning: Meghan Jenkins, GIS Coordinator and HDC Staff member. MINUTES Motion and Vote: Ms. Aldrich made a motion to approve the minutes of the March 2, 2022 regular meeting with one correction (change May 10th to May 11th for the Washington County Gives fundraiser). The motion was seconded by Mr. Lushbaugh and unanimously approved. OTHER BUSINESS Design Guidelines Ms. Jenkins began with a review of the draft Design Guidelines on page 33 (Standards for Review). • Section based on the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards – use quotation marks • Page 40 – Add Settings and Sites after “Guidelines for Existing” and “Guidelines for Proposed” – be consistent throughout the document • Under “Guidelines for Existing” (Page 40) #4 – eliminate the word identical and add “similar species in size and texture” • Page 42, 5th line in 1st paragraph – eliminate “or later historic structures”. • Page 42, 6th line in 1st paragraph – eliminate the word “them” and replace with decks • Page 42, Guidelines #4, 2nd sentence – “This guideline often means” – add the word guideline • Page 43 – Archaeological Resources – caption top picture “Cleaning artifacts” • Page 46 – Building Exteriors – remove “openings” and replace with “windows and doors” • Page 49, #3, last sentence – Research the type of mortar mix that is recommended for use on structures constructed prior to 1900 • Page 50 – illustrations of sidings – add German in parenthesis after Drop and change the Board and Batten illustration • Page 52 – Windows – add a paragraph stating that wooden windows can be restored, repaired, or weatherized can be as efficient as modern windows – Review 2nd paragraph (possible re- wording) • Windows – graphic of a 9 over 6 window • Suggestion: have an entire page dedicated to window illustrations • On the illustration for the different parts of a window, change the color of the dotted lines • Page 54 – Roofs – 1st paragraph – change Mansart to Mansard • Page 56 – Porches – #1 - add a sentence stating that vinyl replacements are not appropriate • Page 61 – Lights – enhance the contrast on the graphics • Page 66 – Solar and Other New Technologies – Add information regarding community solar energy generating systems • Page 66 – Solar (Montgomery County, Maryland, 2021) – reduce the font size and also add as an end of page citation • Suggestion: Ground disturbing activities refer back to Archaeological section of Guidelines • Check with County to determine if historic structures can be repaired or restored in a flood plain (like the City of Hagerstown) • Rural Villages – Brief discussion of actions the HDC can take in the Rural Villages – this is an issue that needs to be discussed at another meeting with more explanations – Make reference to the Zoning Ordinance • Glossary has been updated since last review Historic Preservation Month Ms. Jenkins briefly reviewed the social media posts that will be on the County’s website during the month of May. She will be incorporating a post regarding the preservation and restoration of wooden windows. The National Preservation Month Proclamation has been scheduled with the Board of County Commissioners on May 3, 2022, TBD. Members are encouraged to attend this meeting. An invitation will be extended to the Historical Advisory Committee as well as the local historic societies in the municipalities. Staff Report Ms. Jenkins provided a written report for members of staff reviews for the previous month. Ms. Jenkins explained that the Town of Sharpsburg is interested in getting the County tax credits extended into their jurisdiction. A virtual meeting was held with County staff, the Town’s planner and representatives from the Town Council. Staff is working on researching Memorandums of Understanding for the HDC to perform the reviews for the municipalities. Ms. Jenkins announced the MAHDC Law and Procedures training is scheduled for April 28th at 6:00 pm. This will be via Zoom and will be recorded for future use. Ms. Jenkins stated that the MAHDC Symposium is scheduled for Saturday, May 21, 2022 from 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. at St. Mary’s College of Maryland. Ms. Wallace has submitted her resignation from the HDC due to personal reasons. Ms. Jenkins encouraged members to seek interested individuals to serve on the HDC. There are specific qualifications that must be met per the Washington County Zoning Ordinance. UPCOMING MEETING The next meeting is scheduled for May 4, 2022 at 7:00 p.m. ADJOURNMENT Mr. Lushbaugh made a motion to adjourn the meeting at 8:45 p.m. The motion was seconded by Ms. Aldrich and so ordered by the Chairman. Respectfully submitted, _______________________________________ Jill L. Baker, Director Washington County Dept. of Planning & Zoning XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX X X XXXXXXXX X X X XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXOH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH LINE BEARING DISTANCE L1 N 77°02'32" W 20.16' L2 S 61°37'35" W 123.59' L3 N 63°41'55" W 38.96' L4 N 68°06'24" W 143.50' L5 S 20°38'36" W 13.34' L6 N 06°15'15" W 3.58' L7 N 03°25'48" E 100.00' L8 N 73°27'55" W 99.26' L9 N 06°07'55" W 125.00' L10 S 73°47'50" E 147.40' L11 N 05°17'50" W 134.45' L12 N 00°42'50" W 130.68' L13 N 73°47'50" W 123.13' L14 N 05°58'17" W 26.80' L15 N 20°00'10" E 196.00' L16 N 23°30'24" E 189.32' L17 N 20°00'10" E 188.24' L14 L6 L5OH OH OHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOHOH OH OH OH X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXLANDS OF ANTIETAM CREEK VINEYARDS LLC LIBER 4731, FOLIO 353 55.62 AC. N/F LEONOR MIDTHUN, TRUSTEE LIBER 5405, FOLIO 31 N/F ALBERT L AND JUDY C HETZEL LIBER 439, FOLIO 795 N/F JEFFREY J. HANES LIBER 581, FOLIO 670 N/F TERRANCE L. ROHRER LIBER 754, FOLIO 577 N/F BRANDON SMITH AND ANDREA SMITH LIBER 5791, FOLIO 255 N/F BEVERLY S. HERRELL LIBER 5037, FOLIO 486 N/F BRUCE S. STASKIEWS LIBER 5834, FOLIO 140 N/F USA NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, MID ATLANTIC REGION LIBER 1011, FOLIO 572 N/F USA LIBER 2083, FOLIO 379 Existing Private Lane Is Subject To A 20' R/W Per Liber 1023, folio 986 N/F LEONOR MIDTHUN, TRUSTEE LIBER 5405, FOLIO 31 N/F USA LIBER 222, FOLIO 179 Scattered Fenceline RemainsL17247.08'S 73°01'50" E L16258.86'N 73°47'50" W L15258.86' S 73°47'50" E 246.94' N 73°47'50" W 275.12'N 14°30'27" EL13 L12L11L10 L9L8 L7300.00'S 72°28'19" E 301.76'N 70°46'16" W 284.71'N 70°46'16" W L4 L3 N 63°41'55" W 415.83' 369.44' N 56°54' 4 6 " W 842.44'S 18°02'56" W699.28' S 88°41'45 " W L2 394.55' S 81°17' 3 1" W L1 3 2 5 . 4 2 ' S 1 3 ° 1 2 ' 2 1 " E314.61'N 52°04'19" E1325.77' S 65°25'26" E 937.16'S 72°38'50" E N/F ROBERT L. BROOKS AND KAREN MIDTHUN LIBER 5142, FOLIO 161 N/F RICHARD E. EICHELBERGER LIBER 473, FOLIO 306XXOHOHOHOHOHOHOH N/FLAURA E MILLER AND WILLIAM A. MILLER, JR.LIBER 6181, FOLIO 168OH OHOHOHOH 594.65' Ex. Well589.55'877.18'700.23'PROPOSED PAVILION NAD 83NAVD 88MD STATE PLANEMILLER S S A W MI L L R D HARPERS FERRY ROADONE WAY ENTRANCE ONE WAY EXITONE WAY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE ROAD EX. HOUSE EX. BARN/ WINERY 30'X50' POLE BLDG. (EQPT) POLE BLDG. (EQPT) EXISTING PAVILION EXISTING GRASS PARKING P:\SHARED FOLDERS\PROJECTS\5583\5583.1\DWG\5583.1 PLOT PLAN.DWG 3/30/2022SCALE EMAILPROJECT MANAGER DATEDWN BY SHEET TITLEDESCRIPTION:DATE:PROJECT NO.MARK:©128 SOUTH POTOMAC STREETCIVIL ENGINEERS SURVEYORS LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS LAND PLANNERSF•HAGERSTOWN, MD 21740301.791.365020 WEST BALTIMORE STREETGREENCASTLE, PA 17225717.597.1007505 SOUTH HANOVER STREETCARLISLE, PA 17013717.701.811115 EAST MAIN STREETNEW BLOOMFIELD, PA 17068717.275.7531FREDERICK, SEIBERT & ASSOCIATES, INC.fsa-inc.com••SAI hereby certify that these documents were prepared or approved by me, and that I am a duly licensed professional under the laws of the State of: Professional Certification: __________________, License # _________________, Expiration Date __________________. SHEET OFANTIETAM CREEK VINEYARDS LLCSITUATE AT4835 BRANCH AVENUESHARPSBURGWASHINGTON COUNTY, MARYLANDCLIENT: GEORGE WARMENHOVEN1677 32ND SREET NORTHWEST, WASHINGTON DC, 2007-2931PHONE: (202) 306-51455583.1 AGH 3/24/22 F. FREDERICK FRED@FSA-MD.COM TAX MAP-GRID-PARCEL 080-003-001 1" = 100' PLOT PLAN C-101 1 120220 1 inch = ft. ( IN FEET ) GRAPHIC SCALE 100 50 100 100 200 400 PLOT PLAN FOR PROPOSED PAVILION 707 North Calvert St., Baltimore, MD 21202 | 410.545.8500 | 1.800.323.6742 | Maryland Relay TTY 800.735.2258 | roads.maryland.gov April 11, 2022 Ms. Elizabeth Hughes State Historic Preservation Officer Maryland Historical Trust 100 Community Place Crownsville MD 21032-2023 Dear Ms. Hughes: Introduction and Project Description This letter serves to inform the Maryland Historical Trust (MHT) of the finding by the Maryland Department of Transportation State Highway Administration (MDOT SHA) that there will be no historic properties affected by the proposed Project No. WA461B21, IS 68 over Creek Road, Replacement of Bridge Nos. 2107603 and 2107604. The project involves the full replacement of Bridge Nos. 2107603 and 2107604; resurfacing of IS 68 from approximately 2,000 feet west of Creek Road to approximately 1,000 feet east of Creek Road; full depth reconstruction of a portion of eastbound and westbound IS 68 at the bridges; installation of drainage pipes, construction of stormwater management facilities, placement of traffic barrier and final pavement markings. A location map is included as Attachment 1. Funding Federal funds are anticipated for this project. Area of Potential Effects In determining the Area of Potential Effects (APE) for this project, MDOT SHA considered possible visual, audible, atmospheric and/or physical impacts to historic properties, both archaeological sites and standing structures, which would diminish the integrity of any characteristics that would qualify a property for the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). The APE has been defined as the limits of project disturbance (LOD), as indicated on the attached USGS quadrangle map for Hancock (WV) in Attachment 2. The archaeology survey area is defined as the LOD that is the same as the APE. MDOT SHA has defined the APE as the LOD because a large amount of right-of-way around the intersection of I-68 with Creek Road is owned by the agency. Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 2 Identification Methods and Results Potentially significant architectural and archaeological resources were both researched as part of the historic properties investigation instigated by the proposed bridge replacement project. Architecture: MDOT SHA Architectural Historian Anne E. Bruder consulted the SHA-GIS Cultural Resources Database, the Office of Structures Bridge Database, and the Washington County tax database. Bridge Nos. 2107603 and 2107604 are multigirder beam bridges that were constructed in 1965 as part of the I-68 construction in Washington County. They were altered in 1978. A field visit was not conducted due to the minor nature of the project. The bridge replacement project meets the requirements of the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation’s “Exemption Regarding Historic Preservation Review Process for Effects to the Interstate Highway System,” [Federal Register 70:46 (March 10, 2005) 11928-11931]; and “Program Comment Issued for Streamlining Section 106 Review for Actions Affecting Post- 1945 Concrete and Steel Bridges,” [Federal Register 77:222 (November 16, 2012) 68790- 68795]. MDOT SHA owns a large amount of right-of-way at the I-68 over Creek Road intersection and there are no historic standing structures in the APE. As a result, MDOT SHA has determined that the replacement of the bridges will have no effect on historic standing structures. Archaeology: MDOT SHA Consultant archaeologist Lisa Kraus assessed the potential of the survey area based on review of MHT's Medusa Cultural Resource Information System, aerial photographs, construction plans, street view and LiDAR imagery, and historic maps. No archaeological surveys have included the survey area, and no sites have been recorded there. Historic maps (Taggart 1859; USGS 1901) show no structures within the survey area. Aerial photographs and construction plans (1963) show extensive ground disturbance within the survey area resulting from stream relocation and filling of the abandoned stream channel, the relocation of Creek Road, cutting, extensive fill placement to support the roadway approaches to the dual bridges, and grading. LiDAR and street view imagery confirms that the LOD is largely comprised of imported fill soils. Given the extent of prior disturbance and the low probability for sites at this location, the proposed bridge replacements are unlikely to affect intact or potentially significant archaeological resources. No further work is recommended. Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 3 Review Request Please examine the attached maps. We request your concurrence by May 12, 2022 that there would be no historic properties affected by the replacement of Bridge Nos. 2107603 and 2107604, IS 68 over Creek Road in Washington County By carbon copy, we invite the Washington County Historic District Commission, Washington County Historical Trust, the Heart of the Civil War Heritage Area and the Washington County Advisory Committee to provide comments to provide comments and participate in the Section 106 process. Pursuant to the requirements of the implementing regulations found at 36 CFR Part 800, MDOT SHA seeks their assistance in identifying historic preservation issues as they relate to this specific project (see 36 CFR §800.2(c)(3) and (5), and §800.3(f) for information regarding the identification and participation of consulting parties, and §800.4, and §800.5 regarding the identification of historic properties and assessment of effects). For additional information regarding the Section 106 regulations, see the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation’s website, www.achp.gov, or contact the Maryland Department of Transportation State Highway Administration or the Maryland Historical Trust. If no response is received by May 12, 2022, we will assume that these offices decline to participate. Please contact Ms. Anne Bruder at 410- 545-8559 or abruder@mdot.maryland.gov with questions regarding standing structures for this project. Dr. Lisa Kraus may be reached at 410-545-2884 or lkraus.consultant@mdot.marland.gov with concerns regarding archaeology. Sincerely, Steve Archer Cultural Resources Team Leader Environmental Planning Division Attachments Digitally signed by Richard Ervin Date: 2022.04.11 14:14:06 -04'00' Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 4 cc: Ms. Jill Baker, Director, Washington County Department of Planning and Zoning (w/Attachments) Ms. Elizabeth Scott Shatto, Heart of the Civil War Heritage Area (w/Attachments) Ms. Pat Schooley, Washington County Historical Trust, Inc. (w/ Attachments) Ms. Betty Shank, Chair Washington County Historical Advisory Committee (w/Attachments) Ms. Irene Enweze, Environmental Manager, MDOT SHA-EPLD (w/Attachments) Mr. Steve Archer, Team Leader, MDOT SHA-EPLD Ms. Anne E. Bruder, Architectural Historian, MDOT SHA-EPLD (w/Attachments) Dr. Lisa Kraus, Archaeologist, MDOT SHA-EPLD (w/Attachments) Mr. John Narer, Project Manager, MDOT SHA-OOS Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 5 Concurrence with the MDOT State Highway Administration’s Determination(s) of Eligibility and/or Effects Project Number: WA461B21 MHT Log No._________________ Project Name: IS 68 over Creek Road Replacement of Bridge Nos. 2107603 & 2107604 County: Washington Letter Date: April 8, 2022 The Maryland Historical Trust has reviewed the documentation attached to the referenced letter and concurs with the MDOT State Highway Administration’s determinations as follows: Eligibility (as noted in the Eligibility Table [N/A] [ ] Do Not Concur Effect (as noted in the Effect Table [N/A]): [ ] No Properties Affected [ ] No Adverse Effect [ ] Conditioned upon the following action(s) (see comments below) [ ] Adverse Effect Comments: By: ______________________________________ _____________________ MD State Historic Preservation Office/ Date Maryland Historical Trust Return by U.S. Mail or Facsimile to: Dr. Julie Schablitsky, Assistant Division Chief, Environmental Planning Division, MDOT State Highway Administration, P.O. Box 717, Baltimore, MD 21203-0717 Telephone: 410-545-8870 and Facsimile: 410-209-5046 A_Proj No. 13308 cc: Bruder/Kraus/Enweze Project Location Map Project Location I-68 Bridge 2107603 & 2107604 over Creek Rd Hancock Topo Quad Washington County 08/01/2017 Ü1:12,000 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.40.05 Miles 78°12'12.13"W 39°42'42.501"N I-68 Bridge 2107603 & 2107604 over Creek Rd Hancock Topo Quad Washington County 08/01/2017 Ü Legend Maryland Inventory of Historic Properties Project Location Cultural Resources Map 1:12,000 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.40.05 Miles 78°12'12.13"W 39°42'42.501"N Hancock Historic District WA-VI-040 ?$3( 707 North Calvert St., Baltimore, MD 21202 | 410.545.8500 | 1.800.323.6742 | Maryland Relay TTY 800.735.2258 | roads.maryland.gov April 18, 2022 Ms. Elizabeth Hughes State Historic Preservation Officer Maryland Historical Trust 100 Community Place Crownsville MD 21032-2023 Dear Ms. Hughes: Introduction and Project Description This letter serves to inform the Maryland Historical Trust (MHT) of the finding by the Maryland Department of Transportation State Highway Administration (MDOT SHA) that there will be no historic properties affected by the proposed Project No. WA466A21, I-70 over St. Paul Road Eastbound and Westbound, Replacement of Bridge Nos. 2110203 and 2110204 in Washington County. The project involves replacement of the existing bridges with new bridges comprised of single-span steel girder structures 85’-0” in length. The proposed typical section will carry two 12-foot-wide lanes, a 10’-0” outside shoulder, and a 20’-0” median shoulder, with 2’-0” parapets. The existing bridge profiles will be raised approximately 2 feet to accommodate the deeper superstructure associated with the new bridges. A location map is included as Attachment 1. Funding Federal funds are anticipated for this project. Area of Potential Effects In determining the Area of Potential Effects (APE) for this project, MDOT SHA considered possible visual, audible, atmospheric and/or physical impacts to historic properties, both archaeological sites and standing structures, which would diminish the integrity of any characteristics that would qualify a property for the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). The APE has been defined as the I-70 right-of-way limits because the work will occur in only this vicinity and will not alter the character of the surrounding area, as indicated on the attached USGS quadrangle map for Clear Spring (Attachment 2). The archaeology survey area is defined as the limits of disturbance (LOD) within the APE. Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 2 Identification Methods and Results Potentially significant architectural and archaeological resources were both researched as part of the historic properties investigation instigated by the proposed bridge replacement project. Architecture: MDOT SHA Architectural Historian Anne E. Bruder consulted the Washington County Tax Database, the Office of Structures Bridge Inventory and the SHA-GIS Cultural Resources Database. A field visit was not conducted due to the nature of the project. Along St. Paul Road north and south of I-70, there are single family dwellings representing Washington County’s common built environment from the nineteenth and twentieth centuries standing on lots facing the road. The area is also in agricultural production and there are both fields and stands of trees near the interstate. Bridge Nos. 2110203 and 2110204 are multigirder beam bridges that were constructed in 1965 as part of the I-70 construction west of Hagerstown. The bridges were altered in 1973. Because the bridges are a common interstate element, both meet the requirements of the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation’s “Exemption Regarding Historic Preservation Review Process for Effects to the Interstate Highway System,” [Federal Register 70:46 (March 10, 2005) 11928-11931]; and “Program Comment Issued for Streamlining Section 106 Review for Actions Affecting Post-1945 Concrete and Steel Bridges,” [Federal Register 77:222 (November 16 2012) 68790-68795], and are not eligible for inclusion in the NRHP. There are no historic standing structures n the APE and no additional architectural investigations are recommended. MDOT SHA has determined that the bridge replacement project will have no effect on historic standing structures. Archaeology: MDOT SHA Consultant Archaeologist Lisa Kraus assessed the potential of the survey area based on review of MHT's Medusa Cultural Resource Information System, aerial photographs, construction plans, street view and LiDAR imagery, and historic maps. No archaeological surveys have included the survey area, and no sites have been recorded there. Historic maps (Taggart 1859; USGS 1901) show no structures within the survey area. Aerial photographs and construction plans (1962) show extensive ground disturbance within the survey area resulting from cutting, extensive fill placement to support the roadway approaches to the dual bridges, and grading. LiDAR and street view imagery confirms that the LOD is comprised of imported fill soils. Given the extent of prior disturbance and the low probability for sites at this location, the proposed bridge replacements are unlikely to affect intact or potentially significant archaeological resources. No further work is recommended. Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 3 Review Request Please examine the attached maps. We request your concurrence by May 18, 2022, that there would be no historic properties affected by the replacement of Bridge Nos. 2110203 and 2110204, I-70 over St. Paul Road Eastbound and Westbound. By carbon copy, we invite the Washington County Historic District Commission, Washington County Historical Trust, the Heart of the Civil War Heritage Area and the Washington County Advisory Committee to provide comments and participate in the Section 106 process. Pursuant to the requirements of the implementing regulations found at 36 CFR Part 800, MDOT SHA seeks their assistance in identifying historic preservation issues as they relate to this specific project (see 36 CFR §800.2(c)(3) and (5), and §800.3(f) for information regarding the identification and participation of consulting parties, and §800.4, and §800.5 regarding the identification of historic properties and assessment of effects). For additional information regarding the Section 106 regulations, see the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation’s website, www.achp.gov, or contact the Maryland Department of Transportation State Highway Administration or the Maryland Historical Trust. If no response is received by May 18, 2022, we will assume that these offices decline to participate. Please contact Ms. Anne E. Bruder at 410-545-8559 or abruder@mdot.maryland.gov with questions regarding standing structures for this project. Dr. Lisa Kraus may be reached at 410-545-2884 or lkraus.consultant@mdot.maryland.gov with concerns regarding archaeology. Sincerely, Steve Archer Cultural Resources Team Leader Environmental Planning Division Attachments Digitally signed by Richard Ervin Date: 2022.04.18 15:33:52 -04'00' Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 4 cc: Ms. Jill Baker, Director, Washington County Department of Planning and Zoning (w/Attachments) Ms. Linda Irvin-Craig, Co-Chair, Washington County Historical Advisory Committee (w/Attachments) Ms. Elizabeth Scott Shatto, Heart of the Civil War Heritage Area (w/Attachments) Ms. Pat Schooley, Washington County Historical Trust, Inc. (w/ Attachments) Mr. Ralph Young, Co-Chair, Washington County Historical Advisory Committee (w/Attachments) Mr. Steve Archer, Team Leader, MDOT SHA-EPLD Ms. Anne E. Bruder, Architectural Historian, MDOT SHA-EPLD (w/Attachments) Ms. Irene Enweze, Environmental Manager, MDOT SHA-EPLD (w/Attachments) Dr. Lisa Kraus, Archaeologist, MDOT SHA-EPLD (w/Attachments) Mr. John Narer, Project Manager, MDOT SHA-OOS Ms. Elizabeth Hughes Page 5 Concurrence with the MDOT State Highway Administration’s Determination(s) of Eligibility and/or Effects Project Number: WA466A21 MHT Log No._________________ Project Name: I-70 over St. Paul Road Eastbound and Westbound, Replacement of Bridge Nos. 2110203 and 2110204 County: Washington Letter Date: April 14, 2022 The Maryland Historical Trust has reviewed the documentation attached to the referenced letter and concurs with the MDOT State Highway Administration’s determinations as follows: Eligibility (as noted in the Eligibility Table [N/A] [ ] Do Not Concur Effect (as noted in the Effect Table [N/A]): [ ] No Properties Affected [ ] No Adverse Effect [ ] Conditioned upon the following action(s) (see comments below) [ ] Adverse Effect Comments: By: ______________________________________ _____________________ MD State Historic Preservation Office/ Date Maryland Historical Trust Return by U.S. Mail or Facsimile to: Dr. Julie Schablitsky, Assistant Division Chief, Environmental Planning Division, MDOT State Highway Administration, P.O. Box 717, Baltimore, MD 21203-0717 Telephone: 410-545-8870 and Facsimile: 410-209-5046 A_Proj No. 13312 cc: Bruder/Kraus/Enweze Project Location Bridge Nos. 2110203 & 2110204 MD iMAP, SHA Project Location Map I-70 Br 2110203 & 2110204 over St Paul Rd Deck Replacement Clear Spring Quad Washington County July 24, 2019 Scale: 1: 12,000 0 0.15 0.30.075 Miles Ü 77°53'17.815"W 39°39'5.555"N Project Location Bridge Nos. 2110203 & 2110204 Copyright:© 2013 National Geographic Society, i-cubed Cultural Resources Map I-70 Br 2110203 & 2110204 over St Paul Rd Deck Replacement Clear Spring Quad Washington County July 24, 2019 Scale: 1: 12,000 Legend National Register of Historic Places 2016 MHT Easements 2016 MIHP 2016 Arch Surveys 2016 0 0.15 0.30.075 Miles Ü 77°53'17.815"W 39°39'5.555"N $3( Bridge Nos. 2110203 and 21102041/11/2019 Record #Type MIHP#Record Status Folder Status Status Date Task Name Comments Note 20-Apr-22 Antietam Overlay Zone Review Scheduled for the May 4th meeting of the HDC. Days in Review:28 Folder Status Status Date Task Name Comments Passed - Info 05-Apr-22 Historical Review Proposed signage is replacing existing signage on a property with MIHP I329. This is not in a RV or AO overlay so no HDC review is required. Days in Review:1 Folder Status Status Date Task Name Comments Passed - Info 24-Mar-22 Historical Review Per Meghan Jenkins, the do not need to review, attached email to documents Days in Review:1 Folder Status Status Date Task Name Comments Passed - Info 18-Apr-22 Historical Review Permit is not in a review area for new construction/additions. Sent no review contact letter. Days in Review:0 Folder Status Status Date Task Name Comments Passed - Info 18-Apr-22 Historical Review HDC does not review within the Town limits of Clear Spring at this time. Days in Review:0 Folder Status Status Date Task Name Comments Passed - Info 18-Apr-22 Historical Review HDC has no review authority in the town limits of Clear Spring at this time. Days in Review:0 Activity Count:6 Passed - Info Total 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 5 6Total1 Town of Clear Spring Residential Building Permit Total 0 Residential New Construction Permit Total 0 Residential Addition-Alteration Permit Total 0 Non-Residential Signs Permit Total 0 Non-Residential New Construction Permit Total 1 Review Activities Summary Application Type Application Note 18-Apr-22 LOR 103 CUMBERLAND STREET REPLACE 120 SQ. FT. OPEN REAR DECK CL2022-0002 Town of Clear Spring Residential Building Permit V319 Review 18-Apr-22 18-Apr-22 2 CUMBERLAND STREET INSTALL (10) INTELLIJACKS WITH ENDUROCRETE FTG. TO REINFORCE FOUNDATION CL2022-0001 Town of Clear Spring Residential Building Permit V339 Review 18-Apr-22 23-Mar-22 S-19-038 4312 LOCUST GROVE ROAD, LOT 1 14 FT. X 28 FT. IN GROUND KIDNEY SHAPED SWIMMING POOL WITH 336 SQ. FT. CONCRETE DECKING TO LEFT OF DWELLING, 3 FT. TO 5 FT. IN DEPTH, PROPANE HEATED ANTIETAM ESTATES LLC, LOT 1 2022-01734 Residential Addition- Alteration Permit II0235 Review 06-Apr-22 18-Apr-22 LOR 8900 LUMS LANE 997 SQ. FT. FINISHED SPACE TWO STORY ADDITION ON PARTIALLY UNFINISHED BASEMENT TO INCLUDE, GREAT ROOM, KITCHEN, LAUNDRY ROOM, 336 SQ. FT. UNFINISHED ATTIC SPACE, ATTACHED TWO CAR 2022-01436 Residential New Construction Permit Review 23-Mar-22 23-Mar-22 LOR 4835 BRANCH AVENUE 1500 SQ. FT. PAVILION ON CONCRETE SLAB, PRESSURE TREATED WOOD, PRE-ENGINEERED ROOF TRUSSES 2022-01444 Non-Residential Signs Permit I329 Approved 23-Mar-22 04-Apr-22 LOR 13674 GREENCASTLE PIKE 22 SQ. FT. DOUBLE SIDED FREESTANDING SIGN TO READ "STAR COMMUNITY", (1) 44 SQ. FT. BUILDING MOUNTED SIGN TO READ "STAR COMMUNITY EQUESTRIAN CENTER", (2) DIRECTIONAL SIGNS 2022-01421 Non-Residential New Construction Permit Review 22-Mar-22 Historic Review Activity 03/23/2022 thru 04/20/2022 Open Date Date Assigned Location Description Workflow Info